Nobody believed that only three players were involved in Sandpapergate in 2018. It was just not believable. How could it be, for example, that the bowlers didn’t know? They were the first beneficiaries of the shenanigans and it beggars belief that they knew nothing about it.
Cameron Bancroft caused something of a stir when he said it was “pretty self-explanatory” when asked by The Guardian in 2021 if the bowlers knew. They were emphatic in their denial but they should have been as embarrassed as the boy caught stealing jam in John Arlott’s famous commentary line.
According to Khawaja, the whole team knew. Now that makes sense and is very likely the truth. How would a few players, in a crowded changing room, concoct such a plan without the others knowing?
It must have been difficult for the rest of the team to watch the humiliation and the tears and the punishment meted out to Bancroft, Warner and Smith and stay silent if they knew of the plot the whole time.
I doubt Cricket Australia bought the three-person theory either. But their objective, it would appear, was to move on with as little disruption as possible. Khawaja suggests there was not much of an investigation conducted.
One reason he is convinced of this is that he was seated beside Bancroft in the changing room for the duration of the 2018 Cape Town Test, and yet he was never interrogated. He expected, for a long time, to receive a call from the authorities. It never came. He was a thread they never wanted to pull on, lest the whole thing unravel and the truth come out.
In some ways, the whole thing was somewhat understandable. Rather than involving the whole team it was easier for the three men to accept responsibility. Bancroft had to because the offending material was found in his possession. Smith was the captain and had to go down with his ship. While Warner was said to be the mastermind.
Cricket Australia would have viewed the three-man theory as the path of least resistance. How would they have punished the entire team? That is what they’d have had to do if the whole team admitted blame. Would they have proceeded with a whole new team?
Shorn of the first-choice players it would have been considerably weaker. Australian cricket would have suffered immensely and its recovery would have been long in coming. That is a state of affairs they’d have preferred to avoid.
One thing worth considering: did we make a mountain out of a molehill? I have recently listened to a host of past Test and first-class cricketers and every single one of them say there were always attempts to alter the condition of the ball to make it swing more. Players have freely admitted to using sweets to shine the ball; some say they tried lifting the seam or the quarter-seam.
When Faf du Plessis was spotted using mints to enhance the shine of the ball in Hobart in 2016, he was fined his match fee and given three demerit points. He proceeded to play the next match and even scored a hundred.
But why was the punishment meted out to the Australians so much more draconian? The offences were not the same but they were of the same intent, that of trying to gain an advantage by altering the condition of the ball. So why the disparity, especially since, as far as they knew, it was their first offence? It should be remembered, too, that du Plessis was previously sanctioned for ball tampering in 2013.
And then there was all the indignation, as if ball tampering was unheard of or a great moral failing, when everyone knew it has been widely done for as long as we can remember. That, at least, is what the vast majority of those who have played at a high level say.
I am not here saying that it is acceptable or that we should have turned a blind eye. There is a case to be made, however, that the punishment did not fit the crime.
Warner was banned from international and domestic cricket for a year and precluded from holding a leadership role in the team forever. His leadership ban was lifted in October 2024, however, following an independent review.
Smith was banned for a year as well. He also lost the captaincy and was prevented from holding a leadership role for two years. Bancroft was banned for nine months and prevented from holding any leadership role for 12. There were also some fines levied and some community service requirements.
Were these penalties justified, or did the authorities acquiesce to public outcry that demanded blood? Make no mistake, ball tampering is an attempt to cheat. But imposing such severe punishments is like handing out a custodial sentence when a speeding ticket would have sufficed.



