We have all had schoolmates, teammates and co-workers like Usman Khawaja. We have all lived and worked and played with people who are outspoken, self-righteous and who see themselves as crusaders for justice and fair play.
They have gotten us into trouble as a group or individually. We have all disliked them on occasion and cursed them behind their backs. You don’t really think of them as team players or as people you want beside you in the trenches.
More often than not, however, they are good at what they do. Irritatingly, they normally call things as they see them and are truthful.
I believe Usman Khawaja. I believe that everyone must have known, especially the bowlers. Wouldn’t they have seen the condition of the ball and at least wondered what had gotten it into that condition? Wouldn’t they have noticed the effects, like how much the ball was swerving in the air?
Many of us have been involved in situations where we have shaded the truth or outright lied to cover up for teammates or co-workers or to avoid accountability ourselves. In a way, that is good for the team ethos. You want to work and play and live with people who will try their best to protect you and you will do similarly for them.
I don’t know for sure why it was decided that Cameron Bancroft, David Warner and Steve Smith would shoulder the blame for the whole team. Perhaps it was seen as the easiest way to settle everyone’s nerves and move forward – the path of least resistance as I wrote in a previous article.
The thing is, however, that it was unfair to the three who were punished. Smith and Warner made their way back and resumed being stars for the Australian team. But Bancroft’s Test career was essentially over, though he was brought back briefly, for two Tests in 2019.
It must have been hard on all three. Warner recently revealed that he and his wife lost a child during that terrible period and I’m sure the others had tough times as well. They took the beating for the entire team. There is something praiseworthy about that because it is the kind of loyalty we admire and hope to show ourselves.
Over the years, there were probably two virtues fighting a battle inside Khawaja: loyalty to the common cause and the duty to tell the truth. In the end, it was the truth-teller who prevailed.
Khawaja was also a bit offended that the three, especially his childhood friend, Warner, were blamed and pilloried for something they had done together. The bowlers and other team members may protest and deny it, but Warner said that Khawaja was being 100% truthful, which is what I believe most people think.
That is the only position that makes any sense. I speculate here but being new to the team, Bancroft may have had the urge to make himself useful and might have volunteered for what he saw as an important task: giving his team an advantage.
Earlier, I listened to Jarrod Kimber, that astute observer of all things cricket, say team members formed a circle around the person doing the dirty work to shield them from view. And yet they still feign ignorance of what was going on.
I don’t know what would be the wisest course of action for the players involved to take. Maybe admission of guilt would have far-reaching repercussions that would be especially disruptive to everyone concerned and to the game. But I don’t think we should all be expected to accept a theory that makes very little sense.
I can see no point in reopening investigations into an eight-year-old matter that was pursued with excessive zeal in the first place. Without a doubt, using a foreign object to make the ball more amenable to swing is wrong and ought to be punished.
The fact that it is something that had been routinely done over the years does not obviate the need for punishing the offenders. But the precedent was for much milder consequences and it was obvious the authorities were responding to public outrage.
Khawaja might have earned the wrath of some of his teammates who think he has needlessly revived a troublesome issue that was better left in the distant past.
But I don’t think anyone can seriously and believably challenge his version of what actually occurred. Common sense says he is telling the truth. After all, would he make up something out of thin air to sell his book as some are insinuating?
It is understandable that those who avoided repercussions eight years ago would have supported Khawaja’s revelations. It was a matter dead and buried as far as they were concerned.
A number of players will likely think their former colleague is being something of a prick by reopening those old wounds. It is somewhat understandable they’d feel this way.
They themselves would likely not have exposed long-time colleagues to such scrutiny because of any sense of justice or due to any impulse to do the right thing. Some might think of Khawaja as a bad teammate. But I believe he told the truth. And you shouldn’t rebuke a man for being honest.



